Klondike … my Review

“For a director there are commercial rules that it is necessary to obey. In our profession, an artistic failure is nothing; a commercial failure is a sentence. The secret is to make films that please the public and also allow the director to reveal his personality.”  – John Ford


My opinion? 


Not quite Good. Not quite Bad.

Possibly damned by mediocre praisings.

I don’t make movies. So I’m no expert. I only know what I see. And how I feel about it.

I was happy to see that Klondike was a success – commercially. I like people to do well. And I like assurances that further Western style projects may ensue. Nothing ensures that more than money success.

klondike gold 2

Artistically? Another matter.

On the outset – in looking at any such production: the actors. production values, money, cast, concept, writing, logistics etc. etc. you would think/hope – that any film’movie/mini-series/TV Show coulda/woulda/shoulda been successful – though GOD KNOWS that there are a ton of things that go wrong – sick actors, bad weather, bad writing, poor Directing, equipment breakdowns, lack of time, short of money etc .etc … All of the above – and a hundred other things. And then “There’s always the unexpected” as Jack Hawkins so wisely noted in Bridge on the River Kwai.


As a matter of fact, when I look at all that is involved in putting any such production together, I’m often amazed that anything can come out of such collaborations at all. But, amazingly, something often does.

Richard Madden (Haskell) just came from a supremely high quality production where all components have come together in glorious fashion: Game of Thrones. (And we eagerly await it’s coming new season).

Sadly, however, such quality does not bear fruit in the Klondike. Except for one expensive orange.

Metacritic Score

The Metacritic score of 74 by the criics is generous in my opinion. I fully concur with the Users score of 6.4.

How so?

When it all comes down to any kind of rating in these things, Blame, Shame or Fame, it all usually falls directly on the Director. Bang.

Was he good or bad?

Other elements can interfere of course: poor script, bad dialogue, lousy screenplay, evil weather, actor injury/sickness – a hundred things to fight through. BUT … all we see is the movie/mini-series/TV show … and whether we liked it – or not.

My initial impression of episode 1 is that things seem to be rushed – a lot seemed to be getting jammed into a very short time frame.

This is common problem with such productions – especially TV productions – that may have definite budget and time restrictions. Then you’ve also got to get this damn thing Edited – and on the shelf. Post production. And Logistics are huge. No Director wants to be worrying about production details. He wants to focus on the artistic end of things – and the actors. Not whether the tracks are missing for the camera.

I’m trying to be generous.

As the story progressed, there seemed to be peripheral side events/stories that (to me) added nothing to the venture. The side event with the Natives (for instance) sometimes seemed like a distraction. And was poorly executed.

As well, some the climactic scenes were weak and poorly conceived: a native runs out of forest onto a huge frozen lake while being pursued by horsemen. ?? Who are shooting at him with handguns from horseback – from a distance – when it is clearly evident he cannot get away. There is just one of several feats that challenge our credulity …

Several climatic events are unsatisfactorily resolved. Our very evil bad-guy, Tim Roth, is dispensed with by freezing to death … somewhere? But we don’t really see it – and after all the carnage, killing and injustice he created I felt cheated. Anti-climatic. I would have had him end up in Haskell’s toilet … or some such more worthy demise.

tim roth klondike
Tim Roth – Bad Guy

I also scratched my head at some production concepts: we are informed at the outset that the story is “based upon true events”. OK. But we are not told until the very end that most of characters in Klondike were actually REAL people who had been through these misadventures in Dawson – the Klondike – except for Jack London of course – who most of us would know as the famous author. I would liked to have known about this at the outset because it would have pulled me in to the story and characters more – and also helped explain some of their irrational and illogical behaviours – since us humans often don’t behave all that rationally. 

Ah well. Still glad it happened. Still glad I watched.

Just wished it had been the epic I hoped for.

klondike billboardBut the marketing was brilliant.

Klondike IMDB
IMDB says different.

Klondike mini-series update: “Real-life flood drama hits Alberta-shot TV and film productions”

Hell on wheels – TV Series

Klondike – Mini-Series

Interstellar – Hollywood sci-fi film – directed by Christopher Nolan and star Anne Hathaway and Matthew McConaughey

Heartland – TV Series

” … Oakes’ Calgary-based Nomadic Pictures is also producer of the Discovery Channel’s miniseries Klondike with Richard Madden, Abbie Cornish and Sam Shepard. The period drama, which was shot at the CL Ranch near Springbank, (Alberta), had finished filming but flooding has prevented crews from properly wrapping up the site … ” Real-life flood drama hits Alberta-shot TV and film productions Read more: http://www.calgaryherald.com/Real+life+flood+drama+hits+Alberta+shot+film+productions/8572464/story.html#ixzz2XcMj6vjs

Klondike Mini-Series Update …

Discovery Channel looking for TV gold with Alberta-shot miniseries  Klondike

By Eric Volmers, Calgary Herald      May 10, 2013

klondike calgary herald photo

The set of Discovery Channel´s Klondike in Alberta.

Photograph by: Courtesy, Dan Power ,  Handout

It’s an alarming spectacle to take in. Dozens of extras trudge slowly to a  tent in between takes on the sprawling Alberta set of the Discovery Channel’s  miniseries Klondike, all having an appropriate air of misery about them. The  cameras may not be rolling, but they still appear fairly tuned into the despair  of characters who have arrived in the Yukon just before the onset of winter.  It’s actually a beautiful day in Alberta. Sweltering even. Unfortunately, for  now, this is not particularly helpful when filming on the CL Ranch, a location  west of Calgary where a booming Dawson City has been recreated.

Mother Nature often does her part to add authenticity to Alberta-shot period  pieces, especially those epics with a man-versus-nature theme.

Today, however, it’s hot. Yet the extras who are working are supposed to look  cold. They are bundled up. They wear scarves and hats. The women wear long  dresses and coats. Many of the men sport long, unruly beards. They feverishly  rub their hands together and huddle on what is supposed to be the  less-then-welcoming docks on the Yukon River in Dawson City circa the late  1890s.

“It’s cold, remember,” Assistant Director Dave McLennan reminds the extras. “Brrrrrrrrr. Your hands and feet are cold.”

It’s not just the extras who are feeling the heat.

“We’re trying to pretend it’s winter,” says lead actor Richard Madden,  attempting to cool off on the set in between takes. “I’ve got like 19 layers  here and a dry suit. I’m so hot.”

The irony of enduring a day of uncomfortable heat is not lost on Madden. In a  fairly short period of time, he has experienced some wildly divergent weather in  Alberta. To Game of Thrones fans, Madden is the action-ready Robb Stark, a  sword-wielding leader of men who has travelled all sorts of terrain during his  battles.

But the frigid conditions the 26-year-old Scottish actor and fellow cast and  crew endured on Fortress Mountain in Kananaskis Country just over a month ago  was a whole different battle.

“The hardest bits I suppose were the first couple of weeks, which were  probably the hardest couple weeks of shooting I’ve ever had,” he says. “That’s  because there was the altitude and the cold. You’ve got four wind machines on  you that are the size of a back of a car, or bigger. You’ve got guys shovelling  snow at each wind machine. And it’s really cold. And you’ve got the mountain. So  that was really challenging. You’re trying to do your job and act as well as  dealing with really intense conditions.”

Madden, who plays real-life adventurer Bill Haskell in the miniseries, is not  complaining. The adverse conditions certainly helped him find his character in  the early goings. And it will no doubt help with the epic feel of the six-hour  miniseries, Discovery Channel’s first scripted TV project scheduled to air  sometime in 2014. Based on Ottawa writer Charlotte Gray’s book Gold Diggers:  Striking It Rich In The Klondike, the series mixes real-life events and  historical characters such as Haskell, Belinda Mulrooney and Jack London with a  tale of murder, greed and the dashed hopes of those who arrived in Dawson City  consumed by gold-rush fever but usually ill-prepared and doomed to fail  spectacularly.

Discovery has partnered with iconic British director Ridley Scott’s Scott  Free Productions and Calgary-based Nomadic Pictures, which also produces the  Alberta-shot AMC series Hell on Wheels.

Having had much success with reality shows such as Gold Rush, Jungle Gold and  Bering Sea Gold, Discovery was after a scripted project that explored similar  themes.

“Our audience loves the idea of the frontier spirit,” says Discovery’s  Dolores Gavin, an executive producer on Klondike. “That whole thing about man  versus nature, man versus man, man versus self — those are themes we talk about  everyday on Discovery. There was really no difference when we started talking  about this project because there were those similarities.”

Epic themes require an epic look. Standing on the sprawling Alberta set on  the CL Ranch, it’s clear that Discovery has jumped in with both feet when it  came its first scripted series. British director Simon Cellan Jones, a veteran  of top-tier television such a Boardwalk Empire, Treme and The Borgias, is at the  helm. He oversees an impressive cast that includes Sam Shepard as a haunted man  of God named Father Judge and British actor Tim Roth as a villain named The  Count. Meanwhile, the production seems to have caught its two leads just as  their stars were on the rise. Madden has won fame on Game of Thrones and was  recently cast as Prince Charming in Kenneth Branagh’s upcoming Cinderella.  Versatile Australian actress Abbie Cornish, who plays the entrepreneurial  Belinda Mulrooney in Klondike, is perhaps best know for playing Fanny Brawne in  Jane Campion’s Bright Star and just wrapped up a role in next year’s big-budget  reboot of RoboCop after lead roles in films such as Limitless, Sucker Punch and  Seven Psycopaths.

And while some of the events in Klondike are fictionalized, both Madden and  Cornish did a good deal of research on their respective characters, digging up  books and biographies to help get into the headspace of those who sought riches  and adventure in the unforgiving Klondike during the gold-rush years.

This attention to detail is a hallmark of the production as a whole,  particularly amid the meticulously recreated Dawson City. The impressive set was  built up on an already existing town on the CL Ranch that has been a location  for a number of Alberta-shot projects. With mud-caked roads, newly built  businesses, piles of fresh lumber and dubious-looking meat sold off of carts,  this Dawson City is an alluring mix of filth and boom-town commerce.

Massive dogs — Newfoundlanders, Irish Wolfhounds, Great Pyrenees crosses,  among others — roam the streets with their owners, a realistic touch given that  few horses survived the trek to the Klondike during this period.

“Discovery now knows how to build a town,” says Gavin with a laugh. “With our  audience, we’ve got to ring true to the historical record. The action that is  happening in Klondike was so immense in Dawson City. You can’t do that with  eight or nine buildings, you need 30 buildings. So we have 30 buildings. If you  really go back and look at the research, Dawson City was like Vegas. It was  going 24-seven and you never knew what was going to happen.”

But while this miniseries may be aiming for feature-film production values,  it is still television. Six hours worth of action has to be shot over 54 days,  which requires long hours of perpetual motion in all sorts of conditions.

“I’ve really enjoyed the momentum of it, the impulsive nature of it,” says  Cornish. “A lot of times, because Richard and I are the leads, if we get it in  two takes then that’s it. We’re moving on.”

While Cornish did not shoot scenes on blustery Fortress Mountain, her first  week shooting near Canmore involved learning how to become an expert dog sledder  to believably play the resourceful Mulrooney.

“It was a very full-on week and very elemental and really set the tone for  that landscape,” she said. “If we had just gone straight into Dawson City we  would have no idea about what the outside of that landscape is. We just would  have known the mud and the city and the rain.”

For Madden, the epic feel of Klondike is not only due to the massive sets and  scenic vistas, but the intimate human drama of the stories being told.

“There is a huge part of the stories that can be epic visually because of  what we see,” he says. “And there’s huge parts that are epic when its just a  scene between me and Abbie Cornish and it’s just the two of us standing and  talking. That’s more epic than any mountains in the background just because of  the intensity of the scene.”


© Copyright (c) The Calgary Herald


Sam Shepard To Star In Discovery Channel’s ‘Klondike’ Miniseries …

Sam Shepard replaces Chris Cooper in Alberta-shot miniseries Klondike

Sam Shepard replaces Chris Cooper in Alberta-shot miniseries Klondike

One week after Oscar-winning actor Chris Cooper departed the Alberta-shot miniseries Klondike, actor Sam Shepard has stepped in to fill his boots.

Deadline Hollywood reported today that the Oscar-nominated Shepard, who is also a renowned playwright, will take over the role of Father Judge for the series, which is the Discovery Channel’s first scripted project. Production started last week in various locations west of Calgary, including an area near Spray Lakes.

Cooper announced last week that he could not play the role due to a personal matter. Klondike is based on Charlotte Gray’s novel Gold Diggers: Striking it Rich in the Klondike and tells the tale of six strangers in a small frontier town of Klondike in the 1890s. The cast also includes Abbie Cornish, Tim Roth and Game of Thrones Richard Madden.

Shepard earned an Oscar nomination for playing pilot Chuck  Yeager in the 1983 film The Right Stuff. He is perhaps best known as a playwright, having penned classics such as True West, Fool for Love, Curse of the Starving Class and Buried Child. This is not the first time he has filmed in Alberta. He starred in Terrence Malick’s 1978 film Days of Heaven and 2007′s The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford.