Bill Miner – The Gentleman Bandit

25 Aug

While visiting the Royal VIctoria Museum, (Victoria, British Columbia) … saw a famous photo of outlaw Billy Miner – the Gentleman Bandit

Billy Minor - the Gentleman Outlaw

Billy Minor – the Gentleman Bandit (left)


Canadian Cowboy Country Magazine
Edmonton, Alberta –



bill miner 2
Bill Miner’s prison “mug” shot. Notice the
prison stamp from Okalla Penitentiary,
New Westminster, B.C., 1906.
Photo courtesy Mike Puhallo

Bill Miner created an enduring legend that grew up around one of the Old West’s most unusual outlaws. Credited with coining the phrase “Hands Up” he was known far and wide for his genteel manners and apologetic demeanour. He was the first man to rob a train in Canada.
Born around 1842 in Bowling Green Kentucky the son of a schoolteacher and a mining engineer, he headed West while still in his teens in search of adventure. A superb horseman, Miner drifted out to New Mexico and signed on as a dispatch rider for General Wright during the Apache war. Earning up to twenty-five dollars a letter in this risky endeavour young Bill became quite a big spender and soon turned to robbing stagecoaches to support his lifestyle.
While plying his trade in California Bill was the first bandit to adopt the phrase “Hands Up.” Soft spoken and polite even while committing armed robbery, he would often apologize to passengers for any inconvenience.
Bill Miner was first arrested on April 3, 1866, convicted on two counts of robbery and sentenced to four years at San Quentin. Over the next thirty-five years Miner spent a total of 29 years and seven months behind bars, was released twice and escaped five times. When he was out, he lived the life of a gentleman quickly blending in with affluent society. He was linked to stagecoach holdups and train robberies throughout the West and was once referred to by WM Pinkerton as “the master criminal of the American West.” Miner was released from San Quentin for the third time in 1901.
He was known to have taken part in one train robbery near Portland in 1903 and drifted North into British Columbia shortly afterwards. Using the alias George Edwards, Miner travelled Southern British Columbia, buying and selling cattle, prospecting a little, and visiting with his brother Jack Budd who lived near Princeton. He became well known in the business and ranching community and travelling frequently as he did no one noticed when he disappeared occasionally.
On September 10, 1904 at Silverdale British Columbia Bill Miner, along with Shorty Dunn and Louis Colquhoun stopped the CPR #1 and pulled off Canada’s first train robbery. Months of careful planning netted the gang $7,000 in gold dust, over $900 cash and fifty thousand dollars in railway bonds. They slipped across the Fraser River by boat to their horses and rode a few miles upstream to Chilliwack. The next morning policemen and posse spread out along the border to search for the train robbers. Meanwhile George Edwards, the cattle buyer, was having breakfast and discussing the news with a pair of CPR Detectives in a Chilliwack restaurant.

bill miner 1
May 8, 1906, the CPR train “Imperial Limited” was held up near Kamloops, B.C. by the Bill Miner gang, netting $15.50. The gang escaped on horseback but were pursued by Constable William Fernie and his four First Nations trackers; Alex Ignace, Eli La Roux, Michel Le Camp and Philip Toma. Together they tracked the fleeing train robbers for five days, and the Royal North West Mounted Police were able to successfully capture the bandits near Douglas Lake.
Photo courtesy Mike Puhallo
Caption information from the new book; Interred With Their Bones-Bill Miner in Canada by Peter Grauer-available May, 2006.

George Edwards carried on as before buying and selling cattle and horses, occasionally working as a ranch hand. Never short of cash and often on the move, he was well known and well liked in Princeton Kamloops and the Nicola valley. On October 6, 1905, Bill Miner robbed the Overland Limited just outside Seattle. George Edwards had been working at Douglas Lake a little before that, or maybe he was at Princeton… When a fellow moves around a lot, no one notices when he comes and goes. But whenever a train gets robbed, the Pinkerton Detectives notice. From 1901 to 1906 there where several train robberies in several states throughout the U.S. attributed to Bill Miner but the Pinkertons could find neither hide nor hair of him.
On May 8, 1906, eighteen miles East of Kamloops, Bill Miner robbed the CPR for the second time. He was looking for a huge shipment of cash and gold collected for the San Francisco earthquake relief. I guess old Bill figured after all those years in San Quentin; he was entitled to some of that money too. Unfortunately for Bill, Shorty, and Louis, they stopped the wrong train, got away with only a few dollars and to make matters worse, somebody turned their horses loose. Attempting to escape on foot it wasn’t long before they were rounded up.
In spite of being positively identified as Bill Miner, the old bandit refused to admit anything insisting that he was George Edwards. Hundreds of supporters came to town to protest his arrest refusing to believe this popular old gent could be the most wanted outlaw in the West. Miner and his accomplices were convicted and sent to the B.C. Penitentiary at New Westminster. In a few months Miner escaped, fled to the U.S. and resumed his career. Arrested in 1911 after committing Georgia’s first train robbery, the Gentleman Bandit died in Georgia State Penitentiary in 1913. His tombstone reads:
Bill Miner — last of the old time outlaws.

8 Responses to “Bill Miner – The Gentleman Bandit”

  1. doug clayton August 25, 2014 at 5:38 pm #

    Grow a mustache and buy a hat and that could be you!

    • jcalberta August 25, 2014 at 10:13 pm #

      You know Doug … nobody has robbed a train for a looong time. Might be worth looking into. So I’m looking for another desperado or two. Whadoya say?

  2. cindybruchman August 25, 2014 at 8:37 pm #

    What a fascinating story….I can’t believe no one has made a movie of him yet. He’s gold!

    • jcalberta August 25, 2014 at 10:07 pm #

      Hi Cindy. There is a movie. It’s called ‘The Grey Fox’. Made in 1982. Stars Richard Farnsworth. Almost a documentary style effort / part Western. I’m going to do a review on it right away. This movie is hard to get, but can be watched on YouTube for free. Image quality is watchable.
      Very coincidentally I was watching ‘Monty Walsh’ (Lee Marvin, Jack Palance) (1970) last night and Farnsworth had a small support role. Go figure.

  3. Jorja Campbell August 22, 2015 at 9:34 am #

    Jack Budd aka John Charles Brian Budd aka Rainey McDonald was my great grandmother’s (Dora Brown McDonald aka Campbell later on when she remarried) first husband who rustled cattle from his own mother in law–Nancy George Brown Morris who lived in Carbon County, MT (Roscoe). I have Bill Miner’s San Quentin prison records as well as my mother ordered them to seek information on Jack Budd.

    • jcalberta August 22, 2015 at 2:49 pm #

      Goodness Jorja – that’s a hell of a legacy! Amazing stuff.

      I don’t figure Bill was a bad sort – Wouldn’t have minded sharing a bottle with him. Robbing seemed to be his ‘life style’ – he didn’t really want to harm anyone, but plain didn’t know how to survive otherwise. Alas, I doubt it was a romantic life as he was on the run a lot and spent a lot of time in jail.

  4. Jorja Napoleon-Campbell February 12, 2016 at 10:57 am #

    Yeah, most of his life. Still trying to figure out the Jack Budd deal. It is my belief that they are connected via family.

    • jcalberta February 12, 2016 at 11:06 am #

      I bet that’s an interesting story with a bit of history in there too.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: